Monday, September 16, 2024

5 Key Ingredients to Creating a Cozy Mystery by Elizabeth Maria Naranjo

 


Life is sweet for high school senior and ice cream slinger Genevieve Winterland. Her father owns Sweet Dreams Ice Cream Parlour, the cutest confectionery shop in their little town of Pinewood, Arizona. Genevieve loves her job, but when her father hires a broody newcomer with a dark past to provide extra security on her closing shifts, Genevieve bristles. Is this part of her father’s plan to send her away to college, when all she wants is to stay in Pinewood and run the family business? Meanwhile, everyone’s favorite new teacher at Pinewood High, Miss Love, is receiving death threats, and then she goes missing. Genevieve suspects the crabby substitute, Ms. Pierce, who seems murderous about being passed over for the position. Or is the culprit Mr. Garcia, the longtime instructor who Miss Love replaced after he was fired for assaulting a student? Just when Genevieve thinks she knows the answer, she stumbles across the dead body of another missing faculty member. Can Genevieve find the killer terrorizing the teachers in her beloved hometown—before someone else gets iced?

 

Murder by Milkshake is available in print and as an ebook at Amazon. You can add it to your GoodReads reading list as well.

 

5 Key Ingredients to Creating a Cozy Mystery

 So you want to write a cozy mystery? Good for you! Since jumping into the genre with my dessert-themed YA cozy series, Sweet Dreams Mysteries, I have written with total joy (and often hunger!). The recipe for whipping up a good cozy relies on some key ingredients; if you get these wrong, you’ll risk the wrath of the fiercely devoted readership and trust me—you don’t want to mess with cozy mystery readers.

 Theme: A cozy mystery series has to have a theme. The theme is usually centered on the main character’s occupation or hobby, and you must show your MC engaged in this work or hobby. For example, there are cafe cozies, bookstore cozies, and knitting cozies. I chose ice cream for my theme, because my daughter had recently started working at Baskin-Robbins. I named my fictional ice cream shop Sweet Dreams Ice Cream Parlour.

Amateur Sleuth and Pet: A cozy mystery is not a police procedural; the sleuth is always an amateur. Mysteries are puzzles that are solved by piecing together clues through interviews with several suspects. Additionally, every amateur sleuth has a pet, and pet care must be shown. Bookstore cats are common, but I happen to be a dog person, so the Sweet Dreams pet is a golden retriever. She’s amazing; you’ll love her.

PG rating: In a cozy mystery, there cannot be gratuitous violence, profanity, or sex. Deaths tend to be discovered, often by the main character in sometimes amusing circumstances, and murder scenes are not described in detail. During confrontations or showdowns with the killer(s), the MC is rarely in any real danger for long. Most importantly, there must always be a happy ending.

Motive: The murders in cozies are based on motives like greed and jealousy, and typically the killer commits these murders in a fit of passion. These aren’t serial killers or sociopaths who enjoy the act of killing, but everyday people with relatable motives who are often part of the community. Likewise, when apprehended they tend to explain their crimes in petulant monologues: think Scooby-Doo.

Puns: In cozy mysteries, puns are definitely intended. Titles are clever and cute. Some recent examples are Mocha, She Wrote, Partners in Lime, Thread on Arrival, and Game of Cones. I tossed around several ideas before settling on Murder by Milkshake.

Happy writing!



About the Author

 

Elizabeth Maria Naranjo is the author of The Fourth Wall, The House on Linden Way, and What Was Never There. Her stories and essays have been widely published and nominated for the Pushcart Prize, Best American Essays, and Best of the Net, and her short story, “Windows,” was selected for Best Microfiction 2023. She lives in Tempe, Arizona, with her husband and two children.

 

Elizabeth and Murder by Milkshake can be found online:

https://www.elizabethmarianaranjo.com

https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/8124819.Elizabeth_Maria_Naranjo

https://twitter.com/emarianaranjo

No comments: